Computerized medical record systems.
President Bush in his State of the Union address (2004) has proposed
computerizing health records to reduce costs, improve care, and lower
the risk of medical mistakes. Discuss advantages and disadvantages of
such systems. Do you feel that such systems will have
sufficient guarantees of patient privacy?
Privacy on the Web.
What's happening now? Recent abuses and improvements. Describe Web
site policies, arguments for and against government regulation, etc.
Use of biometrics for identification.
Discuss recent use of iris scan for identification in airports, or
fingerprint use at US border control, or use of face scan to identify
convicted sex offenders or to search for criminals and
terrorists, or fingerprint identification for cell phones. Discuss
benefits, problems, issues.
Use of surevillance cameras
Cameras are used in stores, businesses, apartment complexes,
etc. Wireless cameras are used by private citizens in their homes to
monitor babysitters, elderly or mentally disabled persons,
etc. Discuss use of cameras in these situations. What
are the ethical issues involved?
Personal data privacy regulations in other countries.
England has an elaborate system.
Government electronic surevillance of communications.
Echelon and Carnivore. How has new communications technology made
these possible? Has the technology made them necessary? Are they just
maintaining the "status quo" of government wiretapping of criminals, or
do they increase threats to everyone's civil liberties? What is the
appropriate level of surveillance?
Copyright on the Net.
Issues related to MP3s, Napster, Gnutella, etc. What's being done to
protect intellectual property (music, movies, etc.) and encourage sales
on the Net? (The companies mp3.com and MusicMatch are located in San
Diego; they are possible sources for interviews.)
Copyright and software.
What's happening with "free" software? What is the impact of Linux and
Apache, for example? What are the implications for consumers? For big
companies like Microsoft?
Children on the Internet.
There are several problem areas: availability of material not appropriate
for children, contact with people who seek to abuse children, and privacy
risks from game sites that ask children for extensive personal and
family information (for marketing purposes). How serious are these
problems? What is being done about them? Evaluate various solutions.
Do benefits for children on the Net outweigh risks? Can we arrange to
have the benefits without the risks?
Telemedicine.
From remote consultation to remote surgery. Benefits, possible problem
areas (privacy, errors, loss of personalized care).
Computers in law enforcement.
Issues include benefits to crime fighting, invasion of privacy,
problems caused for innocent people because of errors in databases.
Describe cases where the computer system has been very helpful in
catching a criminal, and describe cases where it has caused serious
problems. An activity for this project could include a ride-along in a
police car. (A few students did this in the past and found it very
instructive.) Another possible activity is to interview someone who
runs or supervises the use of local law enforcement computer systems.
What databases do they access? How do they prevent unauthorized
access? Are they aware of the serious injustices caused by errors in
NCIC files? How do they try to avoid such problems?
Electronic commerce.
Implications for the economy, for privacy, etc. Which industries will
benefit? Which will be hurt? How will daily activities be affected?
Are there significant social benefits or detriments from electronic commerce?
Electronic commerce.
There are many more specific topics. For example, Smart Cards:
uses, benefits, privacy implications and protections in a particular
application or industry. Another example: Several companies are
working on technology for micropayments on the Net.
What will the
impact be (on the structure of businesses, physical store locations,
communities, etc.) if we can easily make little purchases on the Net?
What are the privacy and security issues?
Electronic cash
There are some proposals for
"Internet cash" (anonymous money as opposed to credit card
payments). There are different levels of anonymity (for instance,
an online account may not reveal the name of the buyer to a seller, but
it can be traced by the company that provides the account). Discuss
the issues involved.
Automated systems.
Study progress and safety and social issues related to an automated system
like automated highways and self-driving vehicles.
Safety-critical applications.
Nancy Leveson's book _Safeware_ is a good source. Find an application
in San Diego to study. Or study the Air Traffic Control system, which
uses antiquated computers that break down often. Another idea: Mars
orbiter that missed the destination because of a software
problem. What constitutes an acceptable risk? Discuss the risks versus
costs issue.
Use of computers in restaurants.
Investigation and discussion of the issues such as customer service,
impact on employment, food safety, ambiance.
Spam
What are the problems? Relevance of freedom of speech. The roles of
technical and legislative solutions. Anti-spam software. What is
currently happening?
What court cases have been decided so far?
Censorship of the Internet.
Some aspect not covered in the text, or study some issue in more detail.
Some possibilities: filtering Internet terminals in libraries,
control of the Net in other countries. (For historical background on
libraries: Louise S. Robbins, Censorship and the American Library: The
American Library Association's Response to Threats to Intellectual Freedom,
1939-1969, Greenwood Press, 1996.)
Information warfare.
Will the next wars be fought without bombs? Will computer networks and
computer-controlled infrastructure be the targets of military hackers?
What is happening now? What kind of defenses are possible?
Computer crime, perhaps focusing on credit card fraud and identity theft.
Security vs. privacy and civil liberties.
Monitoring of major
computer networks by the government to fight terrorism and to protect
the security of the
nation's information infrastructure. Is this a good idea? What are
the pro and con arguments? (This could be part of a wider topic on
privacy or hacking.)
Computers and conservation.
How are computers used by nature researchers and organizations. What do
environmentalists think of computers? Are there ideological conflicts?
Political activism on the Net.
How has the Internet helped or hurt political groups outside the mainstream?
How is it used by major political parties and candidates? What is the
impact? How do/should current regulations about political campaigns
affect individuals and small organizations that set up Web pages to
support/oppose candidates and issues?
Violence in video/computer games.
What is the impact on children? There haven't been many serious studies
yet. You could use studies on the impact of violence on television for
background. Interview people who write and publish computer games to find
out their policies and views about violent games.
Use of computers in schools.
How are they used? Are they really helping to teach or to babysit?
Distance learning.
What are the likely uses? What will be the impact on universities? on
adult education? Is cheating a problem?
Policies of employers concerning monitoring of employees' use of the Web
and/or reading employee e-mail.
Perhaps study a few local large businesses. A useful part of a project
on e-mail privacy could be writing sample policies for different kinds of
employers (e.g., for your university, covering students, faculty, and staff,
and for a software company in a highly competitive business).
Cyberspace communities.
Describe some Cyberspace communities. What makes a "community"?
How do cyberspace communities handle decision making, dealing with
troublesome members, etc.?
Gender and minority issues.
The _Journal of Women and Minorities in Science and Engineering_ might
have some useful articles for background and ideas for specific
projects. There have been several studies of differences in the way
men and women use computers. There are many Web sites aimed at
specific minority groups, e.g., www.BlackVoices.com, www.netnoir.com,
www.yavas.com. (The publisher of yavas.com is in San Diego; he might be
a good subject for an interview.) You could study the differences and
similarities between such sites and the Web in general. Other ideas:
Another possibility is a study of students in nontechnical
majors to find out how men and women, or different ethnic or national
groups, differ in their use of and attitudes about computers. Why
there are so few women interested in computer-related jobs? Will
computer learning programs specifically designed for school age girls
help? Is this a good idea?
Computing and network access in other countries.
CACM has articles about the state of computing in several other countries,
e.g., India, South Africa, Haiti.
What will the world be like 50 years from now? How will electronic communications and commerce affect the power of centralized governments? Everyday life? What will happen as computers are connected to the human body? Deep Blue beat Garry Kasparov at chess in 1997. Will human intelligence be of less value in the future? Several experts have written books addressing these issues. You could read two or three and evaluate their predictions.
Voting on the Internet.
A few states plans to have some people vote in the presidential primary
elections on the Internet. Will most political elections be held on the
Internet in the future? Discuss the problems of maintaining secrecy of
each person's vote while preventing election fraud. What other issues are
relevant? How are the states planning to handle these issues? This is real
relevant with the last presidential election.
Using technology in terrorism.
At what point is it ok to sell our technology to other countries? Can we
do things to prevent them from getting into the "wrong" hands? Who can make
these decisions? Can we keep track of these old technologies? Are our old
technologies being used against us? How has the
internet made it easier to get information on information on activists and
bomb making, etc that can be used as forms of terrorism? Use of e-mail
and electronic money transfer in terrorism.
New genetics - information about ones genetics?
Who should get this information? How should it be used? Who controls this
information? How can personal genetic information affect an individual or
society's perception of an individual? Who owns genes and other pieces of
DNA? Will patenting DNA sequences limit their accessibility and development
into useful products?
Genetics and reproductive issues.
How safe is fetal genetic testing? How can or should it be used? How reliable
are the results of these tests? Is it right to genetically alter people based
on these tests? Is it right to select the sex of a child?
Genetically altered things.
What are some genetically altered products? Are GM food and other products
safe for humans and the environment? How will they alter developing countries
dependence on the West? What are proper testing procedures for
genetically modified foods?
Genetics and crime.
How is genetics affecting the courtroom, and police work? When should this be
used and when not? How effective is DNA testing? What kind of tests can be
done?
Cloning.
Is it right to clone? What benefits does it give? What does this do to the
cloned individual? Is this individual treated different than others in its
species? If a person is cloned... is it different than the person it is being
cloned from?
Stem cell research.
Should everyone be allowed to research it? How does it work? What are
the benefits it brings? What dangers does it bring? Do the pros outnumber
the cons? At what time does life begin? Would this lead to a black market
product?
Engineering.
When engineering something what is your obligation to society? How does one
balance cost and benefits when building? How concerned does one need to be
with safety? Whistle-blowing... when is it necessary?
Stem cell research.
Create person? Create and use gene therapy?
Robots in the work place.
When is it ok to replace workers with technology. What benefits does
this have?
What downfalls does this have? Can we ever have too much technology?
What does this do to workers?
Sustainable development of resources.
How long will our resources last? What are we doing to save our world's
resources? What can we do to repair damage to the environment that we have
done? Or can we not...
Prescription drug market.
Are all new drugs safe? How much testing is needed? Is enough being done
before they go out on the market? Are studies done biased? Who is responsible
when a drug has bad results? Is the government doing enough to protect us?
Is it right to advertise for prescription drugs? Does the USDA do the job to
the best of their abilities or do things slide? Does testing
unreasonably increase the cost of the drugs? Should people in US have
access to cheaper foreign versions of the medicines?