Division of Education
Intersession 2003
Education 2101 Foundations and Issues in Education
Instructor: Michelle L. Page Office:
200D
Telephone: 320-589-6405 Email: pagem@morris.umn.edu
Room: Ed 211 Schedule: Sec 1: May 12-13
Sec 2: May 14-15
Educational Leadership: (http://www.ascd.org) Monthly journal with scholarly, yet readable
articles on current topics. Usually has one predominant theme for each month’s issue.
2. Reflect on teaching as a career based on tutoring, observing, reading, and discussing.
3. Observe, analyze, and reflect on classroom life from a new perspective. (Minnesota Standards 3, 9, 10).
4. Explore the historical, social, and philosophical influences on curricular and educational issues
(Minnesota Standards 3, 9, 10)
5. Assess own characteristics and qualities in terms of knowledge, skills, and dispositions needed for becoming an effective teacher of children and adolescents (Minnesota Standards 1-10)
Tentative Schedule
Day/Time |
Topics and Activities |
Readings/Assignments Due |
Reminders |
Day One a.m. |
Introduction and pre-assessment Purposes of schooling- Concept Formation
|
|
The morning's activities are designed to prepare you for reading Ch. 1-3 |
Day One p.m. |
Jigsaw Activity: Social Structure and Equal Opportunity |
Assigned Chapter 4 or 5 |
You will work first in chapter groups and then in mixed groups. |
Day Two a.m. |
Teamwork and then presentations: Multicultural Education and Power and Control in American Education |
Assigned Chapter 6-11 |
Make the presentations engaging. Do pre-reading activities to help Ss prepare. |
Day Two p.m. |
Continue presentations. Prepare for T/A. |
|
|
5/16-5/29 |
Complete 30 hours of tutor aide in classrooms |
Submit Journal 1 by 4pm 5/23; Journal 2 by 4pm 5/29; Use email or snail mail. Submit completed Post Assessment by 4pm 5/29. |
Read and study complete text. Complete DAILY journal following format. Write post-assessment Collect teacher eval (or ask them to send it.) |
Fri. 5/30 9 am (sec
1) 1 pm (sec
2) |
Share tutor/aide experiences Course Evaluation Final Examination |
Complete text Completed journal
|
Be sure to bring the complete journal—including pages already assessed. |
1.
Self
Assessments
Pre-Assessment: In a well-developed essay of 2-3 pages, describe and analyze your attitude toward your own
education, your perceptions of teaching, your attitudes towards students, and other reactions that provide
insight to your current perspective. (An in-class assignment completed during the first class session.)
Post-Assessment: In a well-developed essay of 2-3 pages, answer the following:
a) describe the attitude toward and understandings of teaching and learning that you hold at the end of the course,
b) assess the changes in your attitudes and perceptions between the pre-and post-assessments,
c) explain the effects of readings, discussions, and tutor-aide experiences on your current beliefs and understandings.
2. Tutor Aide Experience
Thirty (30) hours of successful tutor-aide experience. Students elect placement at the elementary or
secondary level.
Observation Journal: Keep a journal of observations during your 30 hour tutor-aide experience. Use the
prescribed format (see attachment) to record date, time, description, and analysis of each classroom
observation. You must submit your journal by email or snail mail twice before returning to class on 5/30. First report is due after 10 hours (no later than 4pm 5/23). Second is due after 20 hours (no later than 4pm5/29). Use formative feedback when completing the remainder of the journal. Bring the completed journal (including previously assessed work) for final evaluation on the last day of class.
Tutor-Aide Evaluation: A tutor-aide evaluation form will be completed and submitted by the certified teacher in whose room you completed your tutor-aide experience. It is your responsibility to submit the completed form to the Division of Education. A final grade of “Incomplete” will be recorded by the instructor until the evaluation form has been received.
3.
Student
Presentation and Participation
Student Presentation: With partner/s, lead the class in an activity that will assess their background information and prepare them to read the course textbook. Prepare a study guide for your chapter.
Participation: Be prepared for class and participate fully in all activities. Attendance is required and will affect final grade.
4.
Final
Examination
Multiple-Choice exam will be based on assigned readings.
No late papers will be accepted.
Self Assessments 20%
Pre-assessment (05%)
*Post-assessment (15%)
Tutor-Aide Experience 30%
Observation Journal (20%)
*Tutor-Aide Evaluation (10%)
Final Examinations 20%
Classwork 30%
Student Presentations (20%)
Participation (10%)
*Items marked with an asterisk should be copied and placed in a portfolio to be submitted during an interview with a member of the Division of Education faculty if you decide to apply for admission to the elementary or secondary education program.
Name
Date: Time:
to Class/Teacher:
Total
hours for today: Total
number of hours:
What I did: |
What I observed: |
What I thought: |
What I felt: |
Analysis:
1.
Your
tutor-aid journal should provide an overview of what you observed, did, thought
or felt and reveal and analyze what you are learning about teaching, learning,
students, and yourself.
2.
What
you observe and what you did are descriptive.
3.
What
you thought and felt are your personal reactions about what you observed and did.
4.
The
journal analysis is an extremely
important part of your journal. It
demonstrates your ability to think
critically about your observations and feelings. For example, you might examine motives,
assumptions, and relationships such as cause and effect, differences and
similarities, hypotheses, and conclusions.
Try to relate the “bits and pieces” you observed to the “big picture” of
the teaching profession. When possible, link your analysis to course readings
and class discussions.
Discussion
Leaders
1.
Complete the following planning form in
preparation for your discussion. Make one copy of this form to give to
your instructor before your discussion.
2.
Prepare a study guide for the chapter and
bring copies for the class. (You can
make copies at the UMM library.)
A.
Engagement: Motivate the class to
think about the key ideas of the article.
Remember that they have not read it yet.
Considering using a case, current event, video, object, or picture to
get them involved.
B.
Development: Prepare questions that will elicit main
ideas, supporting details, biases, connections with other readings or
experiences. Ask question in a logical
order. Move from specific questions to
high level reflective ones. Consider
possible answers and prepare follow-up questions. Include all students. Allow wait time.. Use active participation devices such as
group responses, think-pair-share, or brainstorming.
C.
Closing: Summarize the ideas
brought forth in the discussion. Link
the discussion to the chapter. Prepare a study guide to help the class
understand the chapter. State the main
idea. Define key terminology and
vocabulary. Alert them to key
sections.
Please attach to your post
assessment essay. Name
ATTACH YOUR PRE-ASSESSMENT.
No
Somewhat Fully
1. Describes attitudes and understanding of teaching and learning. 1
2 3 4 5
2. Assess
changes in attitudes and perceptions 1
2 3 4 5
3. Explains effects of readings, discussions,
and tutor-aide experiences. 1
2 3 4 5
4. States, expands, and supports main points. 1
2 3 4 5
5. Writes with correct usage, grammar,
punctuation, and spelling. 1
2 3 4 5
Pre-Assessment
Essay Evaluation
Please attach to your pre-assessment essay. Name
No Somewhat Fully
1.
Describes and analyzes own:
a.
attitudes towards own education 1
2 3 4 5
b.
perceptions of teaching 1 2 3 4 5
c.
attitudes towards students 1
2 3 4 5
2.
States, expands, and supports main points. 1
2 3 4 5
3. Writes
with correct usage, grammar, punctuation, and spelling. 1 2 3 4 5
Ideas
for Leading a Discussion Effectively
As a facilitator of a discussion, you have three key responsibilities, to: 1) create an environment that encourages participation, 2) assist with the smooth flow of ideas, and 3) keep the group on track.
The following suggestion may help you to
anticipate situations that may arise and consider strategies to address them.
1.
Learn everyone’s name and provide
opportunities for others to learn the names as well.
2.
Clarify the agenda—What is the group
supposed to accomplish? The agenda may
be determined by the facilitator, group, or other (teacher, workshop leader)
3.
Establish ground rules/discussion
guidelines and model them whenever possible.
(Remember: people
support what they help to create.)
4.
If you want people to talk, ask questions
that are open-ended (e.g., “Where would you like to begin?”) rather than closed
(e.g., “Do you want to start here?”).
Closed questions elicit only yes or no responses and are appropriate
only when that is all you need.
5.
Allow others to discuss their ideas before
offering yours. If the facilitator is an
authority figure, his or her opinions may stifle discussion rather than
encourage it.
6.
Try to involve everyone.
7.
Moderate the overly talkative.
8.
Stay on track. Pull the discussion back to the subject when
needed.
9.
Use questions judiciously.
10. Legitimized
behavior you cannot control. For instance,
if the group is being distracted by whispered conversations between
individuals, take a break. Or, take a
few minutes for one-on-one discussion.
11. Play
the role the group needs at the time.
This role may be:
Adapted from a document by Kathe Taylor, Ph.D.,
Olympia, Washington, 1994.
Chapter
1
The
Purposes of Public Schooling
SHOULD THERE BE PUBLIC GOALS FOR EDUCATION?
·
Republican—“parents know what’s best for
their children—not the government”
·
Democrat—“creation of state and federal
academic standards will improve economic growth and the conditions of workers”
Academic standards
outline what a student will learn
Tests will determine if
the student has met those standards
(high stake tests)
·
Should we teach toleration of other
cultures, religions and lifestyles? or
Should we teach a Eurocentric curriculum that promotes American culture, Christianity,
and heterosexual marriages?
·
The chapter will discuss
·
The
broad question is the debate between the public benefits versus parental or personal educational goals.
·
Questions to ponder
THE POLITICAL PURPOSES OF SCHOOLING
Political goals of public schooling are:
·
educating
future citizens
·
selecting
future political leaders
·
creating
a political consensus
·
maintaining
political power
·
socializing
individuals for political systems
These goals can be
a source of political freedom and a means of exerting political oppression
Questions to
Ponder:
1.
What
government agency, private organization, or individuals should define the
characteristics of good citizenship?
Should this definition be used to guide instruction in citizenship in
public schools?
2.
Should
there be a consensus of political values in the U.S.?
3.
Should
public schools develop a consensus of political values?
4.
What government
agency, private organization or individuals should determine the political
values to be taught in public schools?
5.
Should
public school teachers be require to only teach the political values given in a
school district’s curriculum?
6.
Does
the teaching of patriotism in schools throughout the world increase the
potential of international conflict?
7.
Should
the public schools of every country build emotional or patriotic attachments to
symbols of the state using songs, literature, and history?
8.
Should
the purpose of teaching history in public schools be the creation of feelings
of patriotism? Should this be true of
all the world’s government school system?
Meritocracy is a
social system in which all members are given equal chance to develop their
abilities and rise in the social hierarchy.
The school is viewed as the key institution for training and sorting
citizens. The U.S. answer to
elitism.
Thomas
Jefferson 1779 |
Horace
Mann |
·
Schools purpose was to identify
democratic leadership for the country ·
limited education for general citizenry—3
years of free ed. to all in reading writing, and arithmetic ·
most talented selected and educated at
public expense at regional grammar schools ·
another select group chosen for further
education ·
Jefferson’s proposal assumed that the
education system is fair in its judgements—individuals judges solely on
talent displayed in school and not on other social factors ·
Jefferson did not believe that people
needed to be educated to be good citizens ·
Political education of the citizen was to
come from a free press—yet he advocated censorship of political texts at the
University fo Virginia |
·
Sec of the Mass. Board of Ed from
18137-1848 ·
Father of American Education ·
Believed that a common political creed
had to be instilled in all citizens ·
Believed that schooling was the key to
the reform of society ·
All children in society attend the same
type of school—“common school” ·
Common schooling and teaching of a common
political philosophy to create a political consensus ·
Problem was that the assumption of the
existence of common republican principles upon which all citizens agree ·
Since the 19th century there
has been controversy about the political philosophy to be taught in the
public schools ·
Another problem is that public schooling
has never been common to all children ·
Mann’s dream of the common public school
has never come into existence |
Teaching
patriotism in schools—began in the 1890s—“Americanization” programs involved
teaching the immigrant the laws, language, and customs of the United States.
Extracurricular
activities led to an emphasis on school spirit—football and basket ball teams
land cheerleaders and pep rallies was supported with the idea was that these
activities improved school spirit and, consequently, service to society.
Problems with
teaching and development of patriotism—because America has a variety of
religious, ethnic, and political groups.
(e.g. Jehovah Witness—saluting flag)
THE SOCIAL PURPOSES OF SCHOOLING
Social purposes of education are
·
social
control improving social conditions
·
reducing
social tensions caused by economic inequalities
Edward Ross,
1890s—American sociologist—first suggested the use of school to solve internal
values and/or social problems instead of family, church and community
·
still
being heard throughout the 20th century—assumption by schools of a
responsibility for teaching moral values—a major debate in the 1990s
·
Republican
party believes that teaching of values and morals is the parents job, not the
school
·
more
parents are home schooling their children
Question regarding the social purposes of
education:
1.
What
are legitimate areas of social concern for public schools? Should public schools attempt to solve social
problems, such as the AIDS epidemic or other epidemics, the destructive use fo
drugs and alcohol, teenage pregnancy, poverty, and child abuse?
2.
What
government agency, organization or group of individuals should decide the moral
values to be taught in public schools?
3.
Should
instruction related to social and moral issues be mandatory for all students?
4.
Should
teachers be required to only teach the moral and social values given in the
school district’s curriculum?
“The hope of improving
society through public schooling has almost become an article of American
faith. Horace Mann believed it was the
key to solving all social problems.” He
believed that there were certain moral values that all religious groups could
agree upon and that these shared values would become the backbone of the moral
teachings of the schools—Religious groups have argued with this and established
their own system of schools (e.g. Catholic church)
What are some ways in which the public schools were
and are involved in moral and social instruction.
·
school
attendance—to reduce juvenile delinquency
·
summer school—keeping
youths off the streets
·
drivers
training—to eliminate traffic accidents
·
courses in modern
living and home economics—to improving family life
·
health
education—to eliminate drug abuse, venereal disease, teenage pregnancies, AIDS
·
others?
Why isn’t it reasonable for schools to be responsible
for social problems?
* because to have the school solve the problem
of alcoholism through health classes is today the problem is one of individual
training and is not related to factors in the social structure.
Why have schools gotten involved with so many social
problems?
·
because it is
easier to give a health course than to change job conditions, improve urban
environments, or manipulate family traditions
·
school is less
threatening than such direct changes
·
changing job
conditions involves confronting the whole organization of industry and the
conflicting interests of unions and business.
·
School is the
least controversial way of planning for social improvement—most conservative
means of social reform
·
Politicians can
call for social reform through the school and thereby give the appearance of
doing good without antagonizing any community interests
What are some examples of using the school to reform
society?
·
reducing social
tensions caused by economic inequalities
(e.g., 1964-65 War on Poverty—Economic Opportunity Act and the
Elementary and Secondary Education Act)
What is educational inflation?
·
Occurs when the
level of education of workers is higher than the educational level required by
available employment
·
the educational
requirements of jobs increase while the actual skills required for the job do
not change—it results in the declining economic value of high school and
college diplomas
·
1970s—labor
market was flooded with college graduates and scholars with doctorates were
driving taxicabs and cooking in small restaurants
·
it can hinder the
ability of increased schooling to end poverty—there must be an increase in the
number of jobs actually requiring higher levels of education for increased
schooling to effectively raise levels of income.
Why can’t education alone cannot solve the problems of
poverty?
“The dream of American
education as the panacea for America’s social ills continues to be plagued with
questions of whose social and moral values and goals should be in the
schoolhouse and whether the panacea of education is just a way of avoiding more
direct and controversial approaches to social problems.”
THE ECONOMIC PURPOSES OF SCHOOLING
The claim is that
public schools can increase national wealth, reduce inequalities in wealth and
income, and advance technological development.
The school can
contribute to economic wealth in the following ways:
1.
socialization
of the future worker into the modern organization of industry
2.
sorting
and training of the labor force—sorting is the identification of individual
abilities and interests and the determination of the best type of individual
training and future employment—this is tracking students into ability groups in
elementary schools and tracking in high schools
THE ECONOMIC PURPOSES OF SCHOOLING IN A GLOBAL ECONOMY
Clinton’s agenda
is to move U.S. schools beyond service to a national enonomy—but preparation of
workers for global corporations and for competition in a world labor
market. –the promise is not reducing inequalities in salaries
between jobs, but educating all workers into higher paying jobs.
Goals 2000: Educate America Act—March, 1994
·
Clinton
administration’s global approach to economic problems
·
Purpose
is to improve the ability of the U.S. economy to compete in international trade
by educating better workers and moving workers into higher income levels in the
global labor market.
·
Development
of human capital (education of
workers to improve the economy)
·
Life
long learning—preschool and adult education
·
Six
original goals established by the National Governors’ Association in 1989 and
two additional goals.
·
Greatest
Changes in U.S. public schools I the creation of the National Education
Standards and Improvement Council to certify content, performance, and
opportunity stands submitted by states and to create national content,
performance, and opportunity standards.
·
Since
1989 various organizations have been creating national standards for what a
student should know in subject-matter areas such as science, mathematics,
history and art. These are content standards. In addition, there is the question of how
well a student should perform in each subject-matter area. These are the performance standards.
·
These
could create a national curriculum. Problem is what knowledge is of most worth
for a student to learn? (discussion in
chapter 10).
·
World-class standards are the national standards—which are
designed to raise the educational level of the U.S. workers to those of other
industrialized countries, and consequently, make the U.S. more competitive in
world markets.
·
School-to-Work Opportunities Act—May, 1994
·
funds
school programs that involve a combination of school-based and work-based
learning
·
supports
programs that link education and employment for new workers
·
support
or school-based career exploration and counseling and the creation of programs of
study that integrate academic and vocational education
·
provide
for on-the-job training with paid work experience
HUMAN CAPITAL AND THE ROLE OF BUSINESS IN AMERICAN EDUCATION
“The extensive and
often unquestioned involvement of business in American schools has increased at
a rapid rate since the 1980s.”
Business
involvement in schools raises a number of issues--it is not necessarily true
that what is good for American business is good for American schools and
students because the major concern of business is profits—this can mean several
thing with regard to public schools
·
major
business expense is taxes-there has been a trend to shift the financial support
of schools from corporate taxes to sales taxes and lotteries—which means that
the middle and lower income groups could be paying an increasing percentage for
public school expenses while business could be paying a decreasing percentage.
·
Financial
donations made directly by businesses to public schools gives the contributor
some influence over school programs—if businesses have money to give to schools
they have the money to be taxed to support schools.
·
Business
has a stake in keeping down wages—educational inflation
Clinton’s
administration’s educational plan for a global economy and business involvement
in education raises the following questions:
1.
Should schools emphasize a broad liberal
education or prepare for a career?
Liberal
education is broad and enhances the joys of learning and thinking, and provides
the intellectual tools and knowledge for making decisions about the quality of
one’ life.
Career
preparation is a narrow education which limits the ability to think about the
broad issues related to the quality of life and happiness.
2. In
a labor market based on educational attainment, will inequality of educational
opportunity cause economic stratification?
This question relates to the wide variation in the quality of schools in the U.S. If the ability to compete in the labor market is depended on the quality of education, then some school graduates will be more advantaged than others.
3.
Will
educational inflation defeat efforts to reduce inequalities in wealth and
income
Educational
inflation could defeat any plan designed to use increased educational
opportunities as a means of reducing inequalities in wealth and income.
4. Should economic opportunities be based on high-stakes tests?
Do high-stake tests contribute to the enjoyment of education?
Do high-stake examinations measure the quality of a person’s life?
POLITICAL ATTITUDES AND EDUCATION
Political
attitudes are directly related to educational policies!!!
Republicans, in
1996, called for the abolition of the U. S. Department of Education and a sharp
reduction in federal educational proposals.
They advocate allowing choice at public expense at public, private, or
for-profit school
Democrats, in
1996, called for increased federal programs to expand opportunities to attend
college. Choice should be limited to
public schools.
Also sharp
division within each political party.
Political
attitudes are also reflected in local school policies.
EXERCISES
1.
Who or what group should determine the
political teachings and political socialization in public schools?
2.
What citizenship training should public
schools provide in a democratic society?
3.
Who or what group should determine the
moral and social values to be taught in public schools?
4.
What social problems do you think the
schools are best able to solve?
5.
What do you thin should be the relationship
between the schools and social reform in a democratic society.
6.
What do you think should be the
relationship between the schools and the economic system?
7.
Should the focus of public schooling be on
career education, or should occupational choice and training be a direct
function of the labor market?
Section 1
Cooperative Learning Jigsaw Assignment for
Wednesday, September 9, 1998.
1. Read
Chapter 2 Profession of Teaching and
Chapter
3 Teachers’ Union & Teacher Politics
2. Be
prepared to be and “expert” on the following topics:
Anna Dalen , Mary Fernholtz and Kari Grossman:
Chapter 2—Teacher
Education in a Global Economy & Control Through Testing: National
License and
Certification
Maggie Grossman, Beth Haugland, and Jennifer
Jones:
Chapter
2—Career Ladders & Salary Increases and Professionalization of Teaching
Joseph Jones, Megan Krantz, & Sarah Larson:
Chapter
2—Teacher Education, The Rewards of Teaching and Working Conditions, & The
Working Conditions of
Teachers
Chrystal Lester, Stephanie Nelson, & Andrea
Scherber:
Chapter
3—Differences Between the Two Unions, A Brief History of the National
Education Association
(NEA), and A Brief History of the American Federation of Teachers (AFT)
Amber Sellin, Mandi VanOverbeke, & Holly
Winkelman:
Chapter 3—The NEA and
AFT Today, One Big Union: The Merger of the NEA and AFT, and Salaries and
Teacher Strikes
3.
On Wednesday, you will meet with the other
students that read the same sections you read. You will meet for 10-15 minutes
to discuss the important points of your readings.
4.
New groups will be formed (one “expert” on
each section, in each group—3 groups/5 people in each group). It is your responsibility to lead a
discussion about your topics so the other students in the group will better
understand its important points.
5.
It is important that you read both chapters
so you can put the pieces together and join in the discussion.
Section 2
Cooperative Learning Jigsaw Assignment for
Wednesday, September 9, 1998.
1. Read
Chapter 2 Profession of Teaching and
Chapter
3 Teachers’ Union & Teacher Politics
2. Be
prepared to be and “expert” on the following topics:
Stephanie Bordson, Erin Jones, & Jennifer Kerkvliet:
Chapter 2—Teacher
Education in a Global Economy & Control Through Testing: National
License and
Certification
Shannon Kishel, Anne Nelson, & Deanna
Rabideaux:
Chapter
2—Career Ladders & Salary Increases and Professionalization of Teaching
Christina Seyfried & Susan Snorek:
Chapter
2—Teacher Education, The Rewards of Teaching and Working Conditions, & The
Working Conditions of
Teachers
Sarah Stein, Jay Sykes, & Jolene Thomas:
Chapter
3—Differences Between the Two Unions, A Brief History of the National
Education Association
(NEA), and A Brief History of the American Federation of Teachers (AFT)
Jessica Waldron, Amanda Weller & Josh Pauly:
Chapter 3—The NEA and
AFT Today, One Big Union: The Merger of the NEA and AFT, and Salaries and
Teacher Strikes
6.
On Wednesday, you will meet with the other
students that read the same sections you read. You will meet for 10-15 minutes
to discuss the important points of your readings.
7.
New groups will be formed (one “expert” on
each section, in each group—3 groups/5 people in each group). It is your responsibility to lead a
discussion about your topics so the other students in the group will better
understand the important points.
8.
It is important that you read both chapters
so you can put the pieces together and join in the discussion.